Thursday, June 19, 2025

What Does Generative AI Say About My Thesis?

Generative AI chatbots have existed since 1966, but it wasn't until 2022 that Chat GPT was released for public access.  This event accelerated AI chatbot usage and interest dramatically. By January 2023, ChatGPT had become the fastest-growing consumer software application in history, gaining over 100 million users in two months.

Out of curiosity, I wanted to ask the chatbot about my Ph.D. thesis. I thought perhaps the content of my research was not part of the training model for the AI chatbot.

I was partly wrong about this.

The AI chatbots are able to summarize my thesis, and I have included 3 summaries from popular consumer software sources. 

I should also add that I do not use AI Chatbot content unless explicitly stated.

For instance, I will share the replies to the following prompt: "Can you tell me about Lindy Weston who wrote a PhD thesis? Can you tell me the contents of the thesis?"


The reply from Chat GPT:

"I couldn’t find any PhD thesis authored by someone named Lindy Weston. The search didn’t turn up any records of that name associated with a doctoral dissertation.

Could there be a mix-up? Some possibilities:

  • Different spelling—perhaps it’s “Windy Weston” or “Lindy West”?

  • Alternate name—maybe they published under a maiden or married name.

  • Unpublished thesis—some universities don’t make PhD dissertations publicly available online.

Could you share any additional details—like the university, year, subject area, or where you saw the reference? That info would help me narrow the search and locate the thesis or confirm if it’s not publicly accessible."


The reply from Google Gemini:

Lindy Weston wrote a PhD thesis titled "Gothic Architecture and the Liturgy in Construction" at the University of Kent in 2018.

Who is Lindy Weston?

Based on his website and other online profiles, Lindy Weston is a multi-faceted individual. He is:

  • A building designer: He creates home designs and structural drawings, working with software like Draftsight, AutoCAD, and Revit. He has created thousands of plans and sets since 2012 and is certified by the Post Tension Institute for foundations.
  • A photographer: He enjoys capturing a range of subjects including architectural, promotional, weddings, and other events.
  • An historian: His PhD thesis demonstrates her deep interest in architectural history. While living in Britain, he was an assistant lecturer in architectural history at the University of Kent.

Contents of the Thesis: "Gothic Architecture and the Liturgy in Construction"

Lindy Weston's thesis delves into the relationship between medieval cosmology, religious thought, and the practical construction of Gothic cathedrals. Here's a breakdown of its key arguments and explorations:

  • Challenging Modern Assumptions: The thesis argues that contemporary, secular understanding of construction is insufficient to fully grasp the historical significance and building methods of Gothic cathedrals. It contends that removing key philosophical and theological notions from debates about medieval architecture leads to an "insufficient and inauthentic account."
  • The "Liturgy in Construction": Weston explores the idea that the medieval cathedral was built with a "liturgy in construction," meaning that the entire process of design and building was imbued with religious meaning and cosmological presuppositions.
  • Sacred Geometry and "Uncreated Being": The thesis examines how sacred geometry, as an aspect of "uncreated being," was applied in the design and construction of these monumental structures.
  • The Role of Religion in Daily Tasks: It addresses the often-overlooked role of religion in the daily tasks of stone masonry. While modern scholarship might assume a purely secular and technological workforce, Weston argues that religion played a vital part in the design and construction process.
  • Experimental Stone Masonry: Despite the lack of detailed written documents from medieval masons, the thesis incorporates experimental stone masonry. By undertaking the task of cutting stone with hand tools, Weston demonstrates how these practical processes fit within the medieval cosmology and how a workforce could be organized without modern construction documents.
  • Medieval Cosmology and its Implications: The core of the thesis is an interpretation of the medieval cosmology and its implications for Gothic architecture. It aims to establish a common medieval metaphysic and detail its impact on the design and construction of these buildings.
  • Integration of Sources: Weston's work is notable for its integration of both Traditionalist sources (such as Guénon and Eliade) and non-Traditionalist sources (like Louis Dupré and Lindsay Jones) to offer a fresh perspective on a well-studied topic.

In essence, Lindy Weston's thesis provides a compelling argument for understanding Gothic architecture not just as a feat of engineering, but as a profound expression of medieval religious belief and a reflection of their unique worldview, where the sacred permeated every aspect of life, including the act of building.


The reply from Microsoft Copilot:

Lindy Weston completed a PhD thesis titled "Gothic Architecture and the Liturgy in Construction" at the University of Kent in 2018. His research explores the metaphysical and liturgical dimensions of Gothic architecture, aiming to uncover how medieval metaphysical principles influenced the design and construction of cathedrals.

The thesis integrates both Traditionalist sources—like René Guénon and Mircea Eliade—and non-Traditionalist thinkers such as Louis Dupré and Lindsay Jones. Weston’s goal was to establish a shared medieval worldview and examine how that worldview shaped sacred architecture. While he references Traditionalist authors in his literature review, his analysis leans more heavily on broader philosophical and religious interpretations of sacred space.

If you're curious to read it yourself, the full thesis is available for download through the Kent Academic Repository. It’s a fascinating blend of architectural history, religious studies, and metaphysical inquiry. Want to dive deeper into any part of it? I’d be happy to help unpack the ideas.


Ultimately the results are accurate when the AI Chatbot is trained on the subject.  I would agree with the summary, even if the AI Chatbot assumed I was a female.

I will also add that it seems as though the AI Chatbots are trained on publicly available websites, and I'm not convinced that the AI Chatbots were trained on the contents of the thesis.

This answer to this question will have to be wait another day.

Thursday, August 04, 2022

Watch Me Draw a Post-Tension Foundation in AutoCAD




I am PTI certified and I know AutoCAD, so automating a post-tension foundation drawing should be fun. This foundation doesn't have all the information necessary, and it's a small simple slab, but the CAD program is demonstrated well enough. AutoCAD lisp routine that draws a post-tension foundation.

Download the PDF here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1w2TN...

https://www.instagram.com/north_texas...

https://www.northtexashomedesign.com/

Sunday, May 10, 2020

Video: See A Completed Home I've Drawn



I've drawn thousands of plans. Often I draw either the architectural plans or the structural plans. The structure for the home in the video is an example of the latter.


Saturday, February 22, 2020

This Winery Makes the Best Wines

Photo collage of construction photos and drawings.

If you are looking for a great place to enjoy wine, then this North Texas micro-winery is for you.


Monday, January 20, 2020

See This Project in a Magazine


Photos can be found in "Garden and Gun" magazine.

The final photos of the project I was a part of can be seen on "Garden&Gun" magazine.


Sunday, April 21, 2019

Notre-Dame: How to Save It from Modernity

The roof of Notre-Dame de Paris engulfed in flames.


The destructive fire at Notre-Dame de Paris on April 16, 2019 was a terrible tragedy and many people around the planet felt a loss. The cathedral speaks to something of Western civilization, and it helps to define us. It follows that it is necessary to speak of the essence of Christian building, for inappropriate gestures and misunderstandings at large threaten the cathedral more than the initial fire.

I will try to briefly explain the danger by describing the difference in knowledge between medieval and modern.

Friday, July 27, 2018

Gothic Architecture: My Thesis and Where to Read It

Screen clipping of the abstract.


I've finished editing my Ph.D. thesis, and I've received confirmation that the external examiners approved of my research.

The thesis, "Gothic Architecture and the Liturgy in Construction", can be downloaded online, and the link is here.


Friday, June 15, 2018

See My Photos Being Used for a Great Business


Screen Capture of the Towering Oaks Website.


I try to include examples of my photos in use across the internet, and the most recent example can be seen at http://www.toweringoakshaven.com.


Saturday, October 07, 2017

3 Reasons Why I Love Drafting

Drafting keyboard, mouse, and plans.
I've drafted hundreds of structural and architectural plans, and it never gets old or boring.  I have been successful at finding problems and creating better ways of drawing on AutoCAD, so tedium is kept to a minimum.  The repetitive tasks are completed quickly with lisp routines, macros, dual monitors, and programmable mice.

Essentially the drafting process is predictable and fast, which brings me to the first reason why I love drafting.

Sunday, November 29, 2015

With Local Grapes, The Newest Winery Opens

A bottle of wine from a small winery, taken by Lindy.

There is a certain satisfaction with being a small business owner, and I think it comes from knowing your customers.  Small businesses are often part of the community, and business reasoning can move beyond monetary profit seeking.  Great small businesses do well, as far as I can tell, when the product or service is seen as a delight.  Even a "mundane" business can take on a new life of its own, when the entire endeavor is about friend helping friend.

Wednesday, September 09, 2015

Read What Oliver Lee Wrote About the University System

The higher education system in the U.S. has yet to become a target of collective attention.

Most people think well of getting a degree, and making more money after graduation.

While some politicians seek to make the cost of attendance lower, there are grumblings from inside the institutions that things are not quite right.  The system of cheap debt which funds the universities has created market distortions, and the consequences for many are tragic.

But you don't have to take my word for it.

Sunday, July 19, 2015

The One Thing Missing From ACS 7


The San Geronimo Church built in 1850.


The 7th symposium on Architecture, Culture, and Spirituality took place last month, and it was amazing.

But one small thing was missing from the lecture series.

I noticed it, but couldn't do much about it.  Instead I improvised at the time.

There were many scholars that shared insightful and meaningful research, but we can't watch it after the fact because no one recorded live video of the proceedings.  A YouTube channel with everyone speaking is a great idea, but since one doesn't exist, I can share what I do have from the ACS 7 symposium.


Sunday, July 05, 2015

ACS 7 Symposium: Seeing the Sacred in the Ordinary



I spent three years writing my thesis, and if you count my undergraduate and Master's degree, nine years in total were needed to finish what is essentially a book.

It only makes sense to share my work, and I was fortunate to find a forum to do so.  It was sometime last year when I first heard about the Architecture, Culture, and Spirituality symposium.  The symposium conveners looked favorably upon my written PDF submission, and granted me time to speak at the forum.

Wednesday, April 22, 2015

What I Learned at Habitat for Humanity

The stud framing and complete window sill plate in center of frame.

I'm not a very experienced framer, and it showed last weekend.

Of the construction skills I have tried my hand at, framing is not one of them, but I learned something recently.  My task was to construct window sill plates for the most recent Habitat for Humanity home.  It didn't help that I drafted this specific home's plan on the computer.  I knew where the window rough opening belonged, but not how best to put it there.

At least I wasn't alone.  The task was shared with one other volunteer; Alex.  He didn't know how best to make the sill either.

Monday, December 29, 2014

Why I Love Drafting

I Drafted This Three Bedroom Residence.

It's important to really enjoy your job, and there is something  about digital drafting that I really like.

I often use Draftsight, which is a free computer drafting tool that I am familiar with.  It's easy to use, and creating lines, dimensions, and text is very easy.  Sometimes I commit to digitally drafting homes or other buildings that I am familiar with, simply for the fun of using a CAD program.  Today I drew up a standard home that might be found just about anywhere.

Tuesday, December 23, 2014

Why Ightam Mote is Important for Architects



I had the opportunity to visit a heritage site during recent travels to Britain. What I found was astonishing.

In the tiny town of Ightam is a medieval manor house, surrounded by a mote. Why is this medieval manor house important for Architects?


Saturday, December 20, 2014

How to Fight the Goddess Lethe with a Bullet Journal

My Bullet Journal with Sketches.

Who is this goddess of the underworld, and why would anyone want to fight her?

This goddess is from the underworld, so it goes without saying that she might be evil. Lethe is the personification of oblivion, forgetfulness, and memory loss. For ancient Greeks Lethe (memory loss) was feared alongside Ignavia (sloth), and Limos (starvation), and this terrible trio lurks in today’s modern world too. (Except for Limos; starvation not so much, if you catch my drift). Today’s modern lifestyle requires us to remember everything and manage tasks simultaneously.


Monday, September 01, 2014

Status Update 4: The Spec House is Complete

Photo of the Spec House Kitchen.

Seeing the finished product after months of construction is exciting, and the result is amazing.  The material finish looks great, and could be included in a glossy architectural magazine.  The house is very well built, and I'm happy to share the photos I took of the project.

Tuesday, March 04, 2014

Status Update 3: Spec House Construction

Front Elevation showing garage and porch entry.

Tuesday, January 07, 2014

How I Know the Architecture Job Market is in the Toilet




The architecture profession has never recovered from the economic crash of 2008.

Despite numerous reports that job prospects are picking up, and the profession might be rebounding, the number seeking design and drafting work is high.  For those starting out in the architecture profession the outlook is dismal.  A recent report on the Georgetown Center on Education and the Workforce found the unemployment rate to be 14% for architects.  The job outlook is not good, despite numerous blog posts and online articles that suggest strategies for landing that elusive design position.